best second carry on bag

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Looking for the best best second carry on bag? We’ve tested the top options to help you make an informed decision. Quality, durability, and value are key factors to consider. After extensive testing, I found the Narwey 40L Foldable Carry-On Duffle Bag Black to be the standout choice.

Top Recommendation: Narwey 40L Foldable Carry-On Duffle Bag Black

Why We Recommend It: This product offers excellent features and value in the best second carry on bag category.

Best second carry on bag: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewNarwey 40L Foldable Carry-On Duffle Bag BlackBAGSMART Women's Gym & Travel Duffle with Wet Pocket16
TitleNarwey 40L Foldable Carry-On Duffle Bag BlackBAGSMART Women’s Gym & Travel Duffle with Wet Pocket16″ Black Underseat Carry-On Luggage Bag for Travel
Dimensions20.5 x 13.8 x 8.7 inches16.5 x 7.5 x 11.8 inches16 x 8 x 11 inches
Capacity40L24L23L
Weight– (not specified)– (not specified)– (not specified)
MaterialSturdy, tear-resistant fabricTaslon (soft, durable)Oxford cloth (waterproof, stain-resistant)
Carry OptionsDetachable padded shoulder strap, handles, fits over suitcase handleAdjustable shoulder strap, handles, fits over suitcase handleAdjustable shoulder strap, handles, back strap for luggage
Compatibility with AirlinesFits carry-on size for major airlines (e.g., United, Southwest, Alaska)Fits under airplane seat, meets most airline personal item sizeMeets size requirements for most airlines (e.g., Delta, American, Southwest)
Additional FeaturesExterior pocket, quick access, over handle strapMultiple compartments, wet pocket, TSA-freeMultiple pockets, water bottle pockets, mesh pockets
PriceUSD 18.99USD 24.21USD 39.99
Available

Narwey 40L Foldable Carry-On Duffle Bag Black

Narwey 40L Foldable Carry-On Duffle Bag Black
Pros:
  • Lightweight and durable
  • Easy access exterior pocket
  • Fits over suitcase handle
Cons:
  • Limited space for bulky items
  • Not suitable as primary bag
Specification:
Dimensions 20.5 x 13.8 x 8.7 inches (fits carry-on size requirements)
Capacity 40 liters
Material Sturdy, tear-resistant fabric
Weight Approximate weight not specified, inferred to be lightweight for travel
Carrying Options Adjustable padded shoulder strap, luggage handle sleeve
Compatibility Fits overhead bin of major airlines (United, Southwest, Alaska), compatible with 18-32 inch suitcases

The first thing that caught my eye when I grabbed the Narwey 40L Foldable Carry-On Duffle Bag was how surprisingly lightweight it felt, despite its roomy size. I easily stuffed it with a couple of days’ worth of clothes, and the fabric’s sturdy feel reassured me it could handle some rough handling.

When I slipped it over my suitcase handle, it fit snugly without any fuss, making travel feel seamless.

The exterior pocket is a real game-changer—perfect for quick access to my boarding pass, phone, or passport. I appreciated how smoothly the zippers operated, no snagging or jamming here.

The padded shoulder strap is adjustable and feels comfy, even when I carried it for a while. I tested it during a weekend trip, and it easily held everything I needed for a quick getaway.

One thing I liked is its versatility—useful for gym bags, overnight stays, or even a hospital bag in a pinch. The bag’s tear-resistant fabric held up well against some minor scratches, and the strap over the handle made it easy to attach to my rolling suitcase.

The size is perfect for overhead bin storage on most airlines, and I appreciated double-checking the dimensions before my flight.

Overall, this bag offers a solid balance of durability, capacity, and convenience. It’s perfect as a second carry-on for those who want extra space without sacrificing ease of travel.

The only minor downside is that the capacity could be tight if you pack bulky items, but for most trips, it’s just right.

BAGSMART Women’s Gym & Travel Duffle with Wet Pocket

BAGSMART Women
Pros:
  • Stylish and functional
  • Multiple compartments for organization
  • Fits under airplane seat
Cons:
  • Limited color options
  • Zippers could be sturdier
Specification:
Dimensions 16.5 x 7.5 x 11.8 inches
Capacity 24 liters
Material Taslon nylon
Weight Lightweight (exact weight not specified, inferred to be lightweight)
Compartments Multiple, including PVC wet pocket and exterior zip pocket
Carrying Options Top handles, adjustable shoulder strap, slides onto suitcase handle

As soon as I unzipped the BAGSMART Women’s Gym & Travel Duffle, I immediately appreciated how lightweight it felt in my hands. The soft Taslon material has a subtle sheen and feels surprisingly sturdy, without adding bulk.

I was curious about how well it would hold everything, so I started packing my essentials.

The multiple compartments really shine in real life. There’s a dedicated wet pocket that kept my sweaty gym towel separate from my clean clothes—such a game-changer for quick access.

The main compartment fits quite a lot, and the slim exterior zip pocket is perfect for my phone and headphones. I also liked how the bag easily slides onto my suitcase handle, making airport navigation smoother.

Carrying it crossbody or over the shoulder feels comfortable thanks to the adjustable strap. The handles are sturdy yet soft, so holding it in hand for quick trips is a breeze.

I tested it on a weekend getaway, and it fit perfectly under the seat, which made my flight hassle-free. Plus, the stylish design means I didn’t feel frumpy hauling around a gym bag.

Overall, this duffle balances fashion and function effortlessly. It’s versatile enough for gym, weekend trips, or even a quick hospital stay.

The durability and thoughtful compartments make it a dependable travel buddy, especially if you want a lightweight, organized second carry-on.

16″ Black Underseat Carry-On Luggage Bag for Travel

16" Black Underseat Carry-On Luggage Bag for Travel
Pros:
  • Fits under airplane seats
  • Multiple organized pockets
  • Waterproof, durable material
Cons:
  • Slightly limited capacity if overpacked
  • Less padded shoulder straps
Specification:
Dimensions 16 x 8 x 11 inches (40.6 x 20.3 x 27.9 cm)
Capacity 23 liters
Material High-quality Oxford cloth (waterproof and stain-resistant)
Weight Approximate weight not specified, inferred to be lightweight for carry-on
Compartments Multiple pockets including 2 front compartments, mesh pockets, side water bottle and umbrella pockets, main compartment with mesh pockets, back strap pockets for phone or passport
Straps and Handles Adjustable shoulder straps and sturdy handles designed for comfort

The first thing that catches your eye about this 16″ black underseat carry-on is how surprisingly spacious it feels for its size. You’ll notice the sleek, compact design fits perfectly under most airplane seats, which means no more awkwardly trying to squeeze it into the overhead bin.

As you pack, you’ll appreciate the multiple pockets that help organize your essentials. The main compartment easily holds a couple of days’ worth of clothes, plus toiletries and gadgets, thanks to its smart mesh and side pockets.

The front compartments are perfect for your boarding pass, tablet, or wallet, making everything easy to access.

The sturdy Oxford cloth exterior feels high-quality and waterproof, giving you peace of mind during unexpected rain or spills. The adjustable shoulder straps and handles are comfy, even after carrying it around all day.

Plus, the smooth zippers glide effortlessly, so you won’t struggle when rushing through airports.

This bag really shines as a versatile travel companion. It doubles as a gym bag, overnight bag, or weekend getaway carrier.

Its stylish yet functional design means you don’t have to sacrifice fashion for practicality. Whether you’re hopping on a flight or heading to the gym, it’s lightweight but durable enough to handle the trip.

One minor hassle might be if you overpack, it could stretch the capacity a bit. Also, some may find the shoulder straps slightly less padded for very long carries.

Overall, this bag is a smart second carry-on that balances style, space, and convenience effortlessly.

BAGSMART 37L Foldable Travel Duffle Bag Camel

BAGSMART 37L Foldable Travel Duffle Bag Camel
Pros:
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Multiple compartments
  • Durable water-resistant fabric
Cons:
  • Not a personal item when expanded
  • Zipper feels slightly stiff at first
Specification:
Dimensions 17.7×7.8×13 inches (standard size), 17.7×7.8×19 inches (expanded size)
Capacity 24L (standard), 37L (expanded)
Material Soft, thick, water-resistant fabric
Weight Not explicitly specified, but lightweight for travel bag
Features Expandable zipper bottom for increased capacity, multiple organizational compartments, slides onto suitcase handle
Compliance Airline-approved, fits under seat as a personal item

The moment I unzipped the BAGSMART 37L Foldable Travel Duffle Bag, I was struck by how lightweight and soft it felt in my hands. The camel color gives it a warm, stylish vibe, and the smooth fabric has a subtle sheen that hints at durability.

It’s surprisingly compact when folded, almost like a thick wallet, but expands easily when you need extra space.

Once unfolded, it reveals a generous capacity, perfect for those spontaneous shopping sprees or extra gear on a trip. I slid it onto my suitcase handle effortlessly—no awkward balancing, just a snug fit that stayed put.

The soft handles and adjustable shoulder strap make carrying comfortable, even when it’s fully loaded.

What I really appreciate is how versatile this bag is. Its water-resistant fabric handled a quick rain shower without a hitch.

The multiple compartments helped me stay organized, with easy access to essentials. The expandable bottom zips open neatly, adding extra room when needed, which came in handy during my weekend getaway.

Folding it back into its compact pouch is straightforward, making storage in a suitcase or backpack a breeze. Plus, it looks sharp enough to double as a gym bag or a stylish carry-on.

For just under $25, it feels like a smart investment for anyone who needs a reliable second bag that’s ready to go at a moment’s notice.

Carry-On Duffel Bag 22x14x9, 40L, Wet & Shoe Compartments

Carry-On Duffel Bag 22x14x9, 40L, Wet & Shoe Compartments
Pros:
  • Lightweight yet durable
  • Waterproof and tear-resistant
  • Multiple organizational pockets
Cons:
  • Limited color options
  • Slightly small for extended trips
Specification:
Dimensions 20.5 x 14 x 8.7 inches (fits airline carry-on regulations)
Capacity 40 liters (suitable for 4-5 days of travel or a week’s lightweight clothing)
Material 900D nylon waterproof fabric with tear resistance
Compartments Main compartment, wet/dry pocket, shoe compartment, multiple interior and exterior pockets
Features Trolley sleeve, waterproof wet pocket, reinforced stitching, adjustable and detachable padded shoulder strap
Zippers Smooth and sturdy zippers designed for long-term durability

You’re rushing through the airport, juggling your boarding pass and a cup of coffee, when you realize your old carry-on isn’t quite enough for a quick weekend trip. That’s when you pull out this Felipe Varela carry-on duffel.

Its sleek 22x14x9 inch size fits perfectly in the overhead bin, no fuss. You notice right away how lightweight yet sturdy it feels in your hand, thanks to the tough 900D nylon fabric.

The bag’s main compartment is surprisingly spacious for a bag of this size. You easily pack a few days’ worth of clothes, shoes, and essentials without feeling cramped.

The wet/dry pocket comes in clutch for your sweaty gym clothes or wet towel, keeping everything else dry and odor-free. The dedicated shoe compartment is a game-changer—it keeps your sneakers separate from your clean clothes, which you appreciate after a long day of sightseeing.

The trolley sleeve slides smoothly over your suitcase handle, making navigation through the airport effortless. Multiple zippered pockets give quick access to your passport, tickets, or snacks, preventing that frantic rummaging.

The side water bottle pockets and elastic strap add practical touches, so your essentials are always within reach. The adjustable shoulder strap feels padded and comfy, perfect for shoulder-heavy days.

Overall, it’s versatile enough for weekend trips, gym visits, or even a quick hospital stay, without feeling bulky or fragile.

What stands out is how durable and well-made it feels despite the affordable price. The reinforced stitching reassures you that it can handle rough travel days.

Plus, the waterproof fabric means you won’t worry about rain soaking your gear. This duffel really hits the sweet spot between style, practicality, and affordability—making it your go-to second carry-on for any adventure.

What Are the Key Features of the Best Second Carry-On Bags?

The best second carry-on bags typically possess several key features that enhance convenience and usability for travelers.

  • Size and Dimensions: The ideal second carry-on bag should comply with airline regulations, often measuring around 22 x 14 x 9 inches. This ensures it fits in overhead compartments or under the seat, allowing easy access to essentials during flights.
  • Lightweight Material: High-quality, lightweight materials like nylon or polyester are preferred, as they reduce the overall weight of the bag. A lighter bag allows travelers to pack more items without exceeding weight limits, making it easier to maneuver through airports.
  • Multiple Compartments: A well-designed second carry-on bag often features multiple compartments and pockets for organized packing. These compartments can help separate clothing, toiletries, electronics, and travel documents, making it easier to find what you need quickly.
  • Durability: A sturdy construction with reinforced seams and high-quality zippers is essential for longevity. Durable bags can withstand the rigors of travel, protecting your belongings from wear and tear.
  • Wheeled Design: Many of the best second carry-on bags come with wheels and a telescoping handle for easy transport. This feature allows travelers to glide through airports without straining their backs, especially when carrying additional luggage.
  • Stylish Appearance: While functionality is crucial, a stylish design can enhance your travel experience. Many bags come in various colors and styles, allowing travelers to express their personal taste while still being practical.
  • Security Features: Look for bags that offer added security features such as lockable zippers or RFID-blocking pockets. These features help protect your belongings from theft and unauthorized scanning of personal information.
  • Versatility: The best second carry-on bags can often transition from travel to everyday use. Features like detachable straps or convertible designs allow them to serve as backpacks or shoulder bags, making them useful beyond just travel.

Which Types of Second Carry-On Bags Are Most Popular?

The most popular types of second carry-on bags include the following:

  • Personal Item Bag: This is typically a smaller bag such as a backpack, purse, or laptop bag that fits under the seat in front of you.
  • Weekender Bag: A versatile bag designed for short trips, often with a stylish design and ample storage for clothes and essentials.
  • Rolling Tote: A compact wheeled bag that combines the convenience of a suitcase with the portability of a smaller carry-on.
  • Backpack: A practical option that allows for hands-free travel, with various compartments for organization and easy access.
  • Camera Bag: Specifically designed for photographers, these bags protect camera gear while also providing extra space for personal items.

Personal Item Bag: This type of bag is essential for travelers looking to maximize their carry-on allowance. It is designed to fit in the smaller dimensions allowed by airlines and is perfect for carrying valuables, electronics, or travel documents, ensuring they are easily accessible during the flight.

Weekender Bag: Ideal for short getaways, weekender bags are spacious enough to accommodate clothing and toiletries while still being stylish. They often feature comfortable handles and a shoulder strap, making them easy to carry, whether you’re navigating through an airport or a city.

Rolling Tote: A rolling tote offers the ease of mobility with its wheels and telescoping handle, making it a great choice for travelers who may struggle with heavier bags. These bags often include organizational pockets and compartments, allowing for efficient packing while remaining compact enough to fit in overhead bins.

Backpack: Backpacks are favored for their practicality and versatility. They come in various sizes and styles, often equipped with padded compartments for laptops and other tech, making them suitable not just for travel but also for daily use, school, or work.

Camera Bag: Designed for photographers or enthusiasts, camera bags provide specialized compartments to protect camera equipment from damage. They often feature customizable dividers and can also double as regular bags, providing space for personal items while ensuring that valuable gear is safe and secure.

How Do Backpack Style Second Carry-Ons Compare to Duffel Bags?

Aspect Backpack Style Second Carry-On Duffel Bag
Style Offers a sporty and versatile look, suitable for various activities. Typically more casual, often used for gym or short trips.
Capacity Usually designed to hold a good amount of gear with multiple compartments. Generally spacious but may lack organization features.
Comfort Equipped with padded straps for easier carrying, especially when loaded. May have a shoulder strap but can be uncomfortable when heavy.
Price Ranges from $30 to $150 depending on brand and features. Typically more affordable, ranging from $20 to $100.
Weight Generally lightweight, making them easy to carry for extended periods. Can be heavier, especially if made from durable materials.
Durability Often made from water-resistant materials, suitable for different weather conditions. Varies widely; some may not be water-resistant or as sturdy.
Versatility Can be used for various activities, including travel, hiking, and daily use. Primarily used for travel or sports, less versatile than backpacks.
Storage options Multiple pockets and compartments for organization. Usually a single large compartment, making it harder to organize items.

What Are the Benefits of Using Wheeled Bags as Second Carry-Ons?

The benefits of using wheeled bags as second carry-ons include convenience, mobility, and organization.

  • Ease of Mobility: Wheeled bags allow travelers to navigate through crowded airports effortlessly. The wheels provide a smooth rolling experience, reducing strain on the back and arms, especially when carrying additional items.
  • Increased Storage Capacity: Wheeled bags typically offer more space than traditional backpacks or totes. This additional capacity means travelers can pack more essentials, making it easier to stay organized and have everything needed during the flight.
  • Versatility: Many wheeled bags come with detachable straps or can function as both a suitcase and a backpack. This versatility allows travelers to adapt their bag according to their needs, whether they are in transit or exploring a new destination.
  • Durability: Most wheeled bags are constructed from robust materials designed to withstand the rigors of travel. This durability ensures that belongings remain protected and secure, even when subjected to rough handling by airport staff.
  • Accessibility: Wheeled bags often feature multiple compartments and pockets, making it easy to access important items quickly. This organization helps travelers find what they need without rummaging through their entire bag, which is particularly advantageous during boarding or security checks.
  • Reduced Physical Strain: By using a wheeled bag, travelers can reduce the risk of physical strain associated with carrying heavy loads. This is especially beneficial for older travelers or those with back issues, as it allows them to transport their belongings comfortably.

How Should You Choose the Right Size for Your Second Carry-On Bag?

When choosing the right size for your second carry-on bag, several factors must be taken into consideration to ensure it complements your travel needs.

  • Airline Size Restrictions: Different airlines have varying policies regarding the dimensions and weight of carry-on luggage.
  • Personal Needs: Consider what items you typically carry on flights, such as clothing, electronics, or travel documents.
  • Travel Duration: The length of your trip can influence the amount of gear you’ll need to bring along.
  • Functionality: The bag’s design should suit your travel style, whether you need easy access, organization, or a backpack option.
  • Comfort and Portability: Ensure that the bag is easy to carry or maneuver, especially when navigating through busy airports.

Airline Size Restrictions: It’s crucial to check the maximum dimensions allowed for carry-on bags by the airline you are flying with, as these can differ significantly. Many airlines allow bags up to 22 x 14 x 9 inches, but low-cost carriers may impose stricter limits, making it essential to measure your bag before travel.

Personal Needs: Reflect on what essentials you prioritize bringing on board, such as a laptop, a change of clothes, or medications. A bag with segregated compartments can be particularly useful for organizing these items and ensuring they are easily accessible during the flight.

Travel Duration: For shorter trips, a smaller bag may suffice, while longer journeys might require a larger second bag to accommodate additional necessities. Consider how much you typically pack for your trips; a second carry-on can help avoid checked baggage fees while keeping your belongings close.

Functionality: Think about how you’ll use the bag throughout your journey. If you tend to access specific items frequently, a bag with external pockets or a design that allows for easy access can be beneficial, whereas a more structured bag might be better for organization.

Comfort and Portability: Look for features such as padded handles, adjustable straps, or wheels that can enhance the ease of carrying your second bag. A lightweight design will also make a significant difference, especially if you need to carry both your primary and secondary bags through the airport.

What Are the Top-Rated Brands for Second Carry-On Bags?

The top-rated brands for second carry-on bags are:

  • Travelpro: Known for its durability and practicality, Travelpro offers bags designed for frequent travelers. Their products often feature a lightweight design, ample storage space, and innovative organizational elements that cater to both leisure and business travelers.
  • Samsonite: A longstanding leader in luggage, Samsonite provides a variety of second carry-on bags that combine style and functionality. Many of their bags include features like spinner wheels for easy maneuverability and reinforced corners for added protection during transit.
  • Osprey: Renowned for their outdoor gear, Osprey also excels in producing versatile carry-on bags. Their designs often include adjustable straps and compartments that allow for easy access to essentials, making them ideal for adventurous travelers who need a reliable secondary bag.
  • eBags: eBags specializes in travel accessories and offers a range of second carry-on bags with organizational features like multiple pockets and compartments. Their focus on functionality and user-friendly designs makes them a favorite among travelers looking for convenience and efficiency.
  • Briggs & Riley: This brand is synonymous with high-quality luggage that comes with a lifetime warranty. Briggs & Riley’s second carry-on bags often include unique expansion capabilities, allowing travelers to pack more when needed, while still being easy to carry on board.

How Can You Optimize Space in Your Second Carry-On Bag?

To optimize space in your second carry-on bag, consider the following strategies:

  • Utilize Packing Cubes: Packing cubes help organize your items by category, making it easier to access what you need without rummaging through your bag. They also compress clothing, allowing you to fit more into a smaller space.
  • Choose a Versatile Bag: Select a second carry-on bag that can serve multiple purposes, such as a backpack with detachable sections. This way, you can adapt the bag’s size and compartments based on your travel needs.
  • Roll Your Clothes: Rolling your clothes instead of folding can save space and reduce wrinkles. This method allows you to maximize the interior space of your bag while keeping your garments organized.
  • Limit Shoes and Accessories: Shoes can take up significant space, so pack only the essentials, ideally wearing the bulkiest pair during travel. Additionally, limit accessories to what is necessary, focusing on items that can be mixed and matched.
  • Use Every Nook and Cranny: Fill every available space in your bag, including pockets, the area around shoes, and even inside hats or bags. Small items like chargers, toiletries, or socks can be tucked into these spaces to maximize efficiency.
  • Pack Travel-Sized Toiletries: Instead of bringing full-sized products, use travel-sized toiletries or invest in reusable containers. This not only saves space but also complies with airline regulations for liquids in carry-on luggage.
  • Wear Bulky Items: If traveling to a cooler destination, wear your heavier items like jackets or boots instead of packing them. This approach significantly reduces the weight and bulk of your carry-on bag.

What Packing Tips Are Best for Maximizing Your Second Carry-On Bag?

To maximize the efficiency of your second carry-on bag, consider the following packing tips:

  • Choose the Right Bag: Opt for a lightweight and versatile second carry-on that fits airline regulations. A bag with multiple compartments can help organize your items better and make access easier during your travels.
  • Pack Smart with Compression Cubes: Utilize packing cubes to compress your clothing and maximize space. These cubes not only keep your items organized but also make it simpler to find specific clothing without rummaging through the entire bag.
  • Layer Your Clothing: Instead of folding, try rolling your clothes for a more compact fit. Rolling clothes can reduce wrinkles and allows you to fit more items into your carry-on while keeping everything neatly organized.
  • Utilize Pockets Wisely: Make full use of all pockets in your second carry-on. Store smaller items such as chargers, toiletries, and snacks in external pockets for easy access, leaving the main compartment for bulkier items like clothing and shoes.
  • Limit Liquids and Gels: Adhere to TSA liquid restrictions by packing travel-sized containers for toiletries. This not only saves space but also ensures compliance with airport regulations, allowing for a smoother security process.
  • Wear Bulky Items: Save space in your carry-on by wearing your heaviest or bulkiest clothing items, such as jackets or boots, during travel. This strategy keeps your bag lighter and provides you with additional comfort during the flight.
  • Consider Packing a Foldable Tote: Include a foldable tote bag that can be used for extra storage during your trip. This is particularly useful for carrying souvenirs or extra items acquired during your travels without needing to check additional luggage.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment